Chicken Fingers Sauces Ideas That Aren’t Ketchup or Mustard

Whenever chicken fingers are served, the usual sauces that come with them are ketchup and mustard. However, they can become repetitive after a while, even though they are always delicious. There are also times that they do not suit your moods, and it feels like you’re looking for more flavors that can enhance the chicken fingers. Well, finding a sauce to fit your mood or cravings is not a tough fix. It’s because there are plenty of simple and quick recipes you can try to make dipping sauces for chicken fingers. 

If you’re looking for other sauces to dip chicken fingers into, you can actually make some yourself. All you need are simple ingredients in your kitchen and some creativity. To help you out, we are giving you some of the best recipes we found for chicken finger sauces that aren’t ketchup or mustard. 

1. Comeback Sauce

Comeback sauce is a classic sauce that is a favorite to serve as a dip for chicken fingers and other finger foods. It is a spicy dipping sauce that will surely add some flavorful kick to chicken fingers. The ingredients needed for this sauce are mayonnaise, ketchup, hot sauce, Worcestershire sauce, garlic powder, and black pepper. You just need to mix these ingredients together to make a delicious dipping sauce for chicken fingers. You can view the full recipe of this sauce here

2. Creamy Avocado Dip 

If you want something unique for your chicken fingers sauce, then you should try making some creamy avocado dip. It is a Greek yogurt-based sauce blended with tangy lime juice and smoky cumin. Aside from chicken fingers, this sauce can also be used with tacos, fajitas, taquitos, and other finger foods. You can check the full recipe of this sauce at Gal on a Mission

3. Bourbon Bacon Jam

How about a sauce made of bacon for chicken fingers? This will surely add another layer of flavor to your favorite finger food. This sauce is so good that you can even eat it alone. But it will really go well with chicken fingers and other foods, even with pasta. The ingredients you need for this sauce are bacon, shallots, onion, garlic, chili powder, smoked paprika, bourbon, maple syrup, balsamic vinegar, brown sugar. If you want to know how to make this delicious sauce, you can check the full recipe here

4. Cashew-Ginger Dipping Sauce

We discovered this chicken fingers dipping sauce from My Recipes. It is made using creamy cashew butter, warm water, soy sauce, rice vinegar, fresh ginger, sugar, and dried crushed red pepper. Aside from dipping chicken fingers, this sauce can also be used to serve up raw vegetables and to coat fresh garden produce. It is a spicy and delicious sauce that will add flavor to chicken fingers. 

5. Chimichurri Sauce

Chimichurri is a combination of herbs, such as cilantro and parsley. It also includes some red pepper flakes, raw garlic for some heat, and vinegar for its nice tangy aftertaste. Chimichurri is a popular sauce for steak, but it is also a great dip for chicken fingers and pulled pork. If you want to make some chimichurri sauce for your chicken fingers, then you can see the full recipe at Bon Appetit

6. Cilantro Jalapeño Sauce

This one is a sour cream-based sauce that is perfect for dipping chicken fingers as well. You can also dip some chips and French fries into it. Damn Delicious shared the recipe for this sauce. It is very easy to make and will only take you 5 minutes. All you need are some jalapeños, cilantro, sour cream, garlic, lime, salt, olive oil, and apple cider vinegar. It is a delicious and healthy sauce for chicken fingers. 

7. Szechuan Teriyaki Sauce

McDonald’s had their limited-time Szechuan teriyaki sauce, which tastes great with chicken fingers. But if you’re unable to taste that sauce, don’t fret because you can recreate it at home by following The Food Hacker’s recipe. All you need for this sauce is some soy sauce, water, ginger paste, minced garlic, sesame oil, salt, cornstarch, sugar, ground Szechuan peppercorns, black pepper, coriander, rice vinegar, apple cider vinegar, and lime juice. You will truly enjoy your chicken fingers, the McDonald’s way with this sauce. 

8. Sweet Chili Soy Sauce

Soy sauce is a simple but great dip for chicken fingers. But you can spice it up a bit by adding some sugar and spicy chili to it to make the savory sauce complex and delicious. Aside from chicken fingers, you can also use this dip for cheesy vegetable fritters and grilled meats. You can see the full recipe for this sauce at Simply Delicious

9. Tzatziki Sauce

This is a Greek sauce, but it is not exclusive to Middle Eastern food because you can also dip some chicken fingers into it. This sauce is a combination of cucumbers and Greek yogurt. It also includes some lemon juice and garlic for more flavor. It also goes well with spicy fried chicken and as well as grilled meats and vegetables. If you want to know how to make this sauce, you can check the recipe at Natasha’s Kitchen

10. Romesco Sauce

Romesco is a classic Spanish sauce that you can pair well with anything, including chicken fingers. You can also match it with grilled vegetables and shrimp skewers because it accentuates grilled flavors very well. It is a nutty and fruity sauce that can be served in many ways. It is made using tomatoes, garlic, ancho chili peppers, toasted bread, red wine, toasted almonds, extra-virgin olive oil, and Kosher salt. You can get the full recipe of the Romesco sauce at Serious Eats

11. Ranch Sauce

Ranch sauce was originally a salad dressing, but it is widely used today as a sauce. It is made using herbs, spices, onions, buttermilk, and mustard. 

Mayonnaise, yogurt, or sour cream may also be added for extra flavor. Ranch sauce has a creamy taste that goes very well with chicken fingers. Many variations of ranch dipping sauce exist. Some recipes also use avocados. 

You can customize the sauce as much as you want for the best flavor.

12. Thai Dipping Sauce


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Yummy App (@yummy.idn)

Thai dipping sauce will give your chicken fingers a sour and sweet taste. The sauce’s flavor tends to be very balanced, making it very enjoyable. It is made using ginger roots, chili flakes, vinegar, and turbinado sugar.

These ingredients give the sauce a unique and pleasing aroma and flavor, making your chicken fingers even tastier.

13. Barbeque Sauce

Barbeque sauce can easily be made at home. It usually has a spicy flavor because of vinegar, tomato paste, and strong spices used to make it. Although some recipes also use sweeteners and mayonnaise. 

Barbeque sauces can give a spicy flavor to your chicken fingers. 

14. Buffalo Sauce

Some people do not like mayonnaise, which makes barbeque sauce unsuitable for them. For them, buffalo sauce is the best alternative. It is made of vinegar, spices, peppers, and garlic powder. 

Moreover, buffalo sauce has a spicy flavor making it popular with spice lovers.  

15. Salsa Dipping Sauce

Salsa is an excellent classic companion of chicken dishes. Thanks to its fresh and spicy flavor, it will definitely go well with chicken fingers.

Salsa is usually made using onions, herbs, and chopped tomatoes. Some people also like to add fruits like peaches into the blend. Salsa can also be combined with sour cream and cheese to give it a creamier taste.

For more information on salsa dips, click here.

16. Zaxby’s Dipping Sauce

Zaxby’s dipping sauce is made using Worcestershire sauce, mayo, and ketchup. Some other spices are also added to give it extra flavor. It is one of the best dipping sauces for chicken fingers.

Zaxby’s sauce has a taste similar to barbeque sauce, yet it is unique in its own way. It is pretty easy to make at home, requiring ingredients you may already have in your kitchen.

17. Tahini Dipping Sauce

Tahini is not as well-known as some other entries on this list. Still, it is a great sauce to accompany chicken fingers. Its unique flavor will quickly make you love it. You can easily make tahini sauce at home using sesame, lemon juice, olive oil, and garlic.  

These are some of the best chicken fingers sauces we can recommend that aren’t ketchup or mustard. These sauces will surely give chicken fingers a twist, making them tastier and more flavorful.